QUOTE (Apsara Lute Ly @ Nov 24 2008, 10:29 PM)

There's too much scat. Perhaps you could have dialed it down a bit.
Merely allude to the girl's continence problems in the intro, and have a single, dramatic scat moment somewhere in the body of the story. Employ it as a literary device, but don't overdo it. Perhaps 'less' could be 'more' there.
It could be enough that she's simply drooling and illiterate.
That's all probably a matter of individual taste.
Of the story itself, you should send it through an editor. Some of the phrasing could be changed a bit.
This is a good story in any event.
Sometimes the scat and such are so outlandish as to cause the reader entry into previously unexplored literary milieus.
The ending here is really strong.
The narrator passage is either 'take it or leave it.' The story is good with or without it. I liked it.
'Devon' is a pretty good writer. If his stories were edited a bit, they might really fly.
Only he knows who 'his' intended audience really is. Barry Manilow once said of writing hit songs, "I would be a fool to write songs that only myself and a few close friends liked, wouldn't I?"
On a past thread, Devon said some good things about Lovecraft. I agree with him about that. Lovecraft is like the gold standard of horror literature. Not the August Derleth, 'collaborations' but the stuff written entirely by HP himself.
If Devon and Grace are really two different people, Devon should send his stories to Grace for editing.
But yeah, good story there. The one about the fake psychiatrist was good too...
As for horror, another writer to check out is EA Poe. He could write.
Going with the idea that there are multiple people actually posting at this forum, you gotta give Devon credit for one thing; he brings stories.
It's the writings which have been collected here which make this forum interesting:
Gotterdammerung, Jody, Devon, Green, FPY, etc...
It would be something else to see PWR morph into a sort of writer's forum.
Anyone out there want to write any stories and post, I'll read and comment...
A story posting is better than any picture, youtube, or fringe news article.
I am indeed honored that someone as talented as you read and respond! I am only one person and not related to anyone else, but you put me in some pretty dramatic company, yourself included. I too like Lovecraft and his French counterpart Villiers de l'Isle-Adam, who wrote a great deal of very spooky short horror stories but was never as voluminous as Lovecraft. I also like Poe and have been inspired by him, as well as Hawthorne and Guy de Maupassant. Can't fail to mention Arthur Machen, either. All great horror writers.
I probably did push the scatology a little too far. I'm glad you pointed this out. A writer above says that I make some errors regarding the abused and retarded, and I have to agree that I only know them from afar. So the bowel accidents aspect of my story, which I will allow to remain (I rarely edit, unfortunately), may have been "de trop."
I appreciate the good things you found in my story too. Also, I'm glad you liked a previous one. I am up to around 12 or 13 in the library now. Some better or worse than others. I hope you have a chance to read more. In saying this to you, I need to confess, WITH MUCH EMBARRASSMENT, that I have not yet finished your last story. The first one was dynamite. I printed it out in larger fond to read at leisure, and I liked it. I have the second one printed and must today return to it.
Like you, I will read any fiction posted here, and I like the idea of the forum turning into an outlet for creative fiction. That would be a good turn in my opinion, one that I have been working on since I started posting. It was my original intent to bring out other writers like you and Grace. Jody Casgraine was my greatest inspiration, and it was she who brought me to post fiction here rather than in other places. FPY was also interesting to read.
Above all, Jody stands out. There has never been anything like her on the internet before or since. I am only a pale imitation of what she was.
I like to think that my contribution to this forum is not only my stories but the encouragement of other writers like yourself and Grace. In reality, it does not in fact take a great deal of courage to hit the post button. No important artist of any kind should be hindered by negative receptions. We have to write to please ourselves first and then hope that a few others get it. Here and on other forums, I have seen aspiring writers START something good only to not know how to FINISH it. As a writer yourself, you are aware that finishing may be the most difficult part. I write an entire story in my mind and then find the tone and language for it later.
All in all, an excellent critique from you, and I encourage you to continue, and I WILL read.
Devon